Read the winning piece of our 2025 Nonfiction Contest “Through the Mirror” by Jessie Cato selected by Lucy Ives.

Read

June 12, 2012 KR Blog Blog Chats Enthusiasms

Reason Not the Need

I do not need religion. I can plug that hole with anything: family, literature, music, medicine. I can distract myself and go along and never look up and die quite happy. The problem is: I want religion. Why? Why do I want this supernatural, irrational hypothesis—if I concede I do not need it?

I treasure my irrationality. (So, whether or not you realize it, do you.) Love is at its best irrational. I do not want to be rationally loved. I want to be irrationally loved. And I want to love irrationally in return. Faith is, like love, one of the beautiful irrationalities in my life. The best things in my life are the things I do not need. (Literature, for example, I do not need. My reason knows that I could live very comfortably without reading and writing books. Yes, reason, but I still want literature in my life!) I treasure reason, too, but logic and scientific study (which I have done all too much of) have never exhilarated me like love or faith. I am a human being; I am by nature a hybrid of rational and irrational. I do not choose between the two; I cannot choose between the two, no more than I can choose one parent’s genes and not the other’s. But I can rank them and live accordingly. I treasure what is irrational above what is rational. This simple hierarchy is why I am a religious man.