New England Saints by Austin Warren. University of Michigan. $3.75.
Austin Warren’s book of essays on a group of New England worthies has a striking jacket: a landscape blotted out in snow except for a section of rail fence, and, on the back and spine, a leafless, untended apple tree. The two are united by a thin row of weeds which mark the tenuous line between earth and sky. Most of the men about whom Warren writes made light of that line. He calls them saints because they were men “to whom reality was the spiritual life, whose spiritual integrity was their calling and vocation.” It is easy to differ with him about the fruits that each produced; Warren tastes frozen Jonathan in some cases which I think mere McIntosh (Alcott, for instance), but once I had read it this book seemed indispensable. There are ten essays: a previous publication is noted for those on Alcott, Emerson, the elder Henry James, Charles Eliot Norton, and Irving Babbitt. The others have to do with the American Puritan poets, a group of lives of New England preachers, Fenelon, Father Taylor (Melville’s “Father Mapple”), and John Brooks Wheelwright, Bostonian and poet. The essay on the poets of Massachusetts Bay in this volume, when read in conjunction with that on Edward Taylor in Rage for Order, comprises a brilliant introduction to the verse of the period. Two other pieces do what no one else has done so well: “‘Father’s Ideas’: the elder Henry James,” and “Father Taylor, or, Metaphor Among the Methodists.”
