Read the winning piece of our 2025 Nonfiction Contest “Through the Mirror” by Jessie Cato selected by Lucy Ives.

Read

Winter 1946 • Vol. VIII No. 1 • Book Reviews |

Lyrical and Social Too

No Triumph by John Malcolm Brinnin. Knopf. $2.00

Poetic diffuseness and disrelation in theme and approach have been brought to rein with Brinnin’s main theme in his third volume, No Arch, No Triumph. And his early talents in lyrical music, image, adjectives of charm and shock, now figure in a vigorous instrumentation. These new maturities have been achieved by the two poets who are always at work on his poetry: the lyric poet and poet of social ideas. Quite simply, Brinnin has worked social idea into poetic form, and belief into music, as well as any poet in his generation; and he has made as significant an achievement with his poetry as the young English group—Thomas or Moore—and the Americans—Rukeyser or Shapiro.

Naturally, the two poets in him might often conflict, even in a single line: criticism, if it wishes to evaluate the real worth of Brinnin, should consider the duality of purpose, method, and perception. The social poet perceives the reality of any situation, ideologically first, emotionally second, because indignation is of the intellect, sorrow and anger of the emotion. It follows that Brinnin must be read with the eyes and ears receiving two poetries, not one: he intends that lyric shall shuttle into explanation and back, that idea shall weave into song, and that image and song shall become idea. This is the technic that can make for lasting worth: it is the technic in which one simplifies only after the wholeness of experience has been brought to the poem; then by selecting the associational image or music that will convey it and by using the expositional line to evaluate it, Brinnin uses a process of simplification and instrumentation perhaps in emulation of Milton. And modern poetry could stand a great deal more of this, or at least more of Brinnin’s intention.

The matter with much critical acceptance of Brinnin’s new work is that Marxian critics feel betrayed by his lyricism; the lyricist-critics feel betrayed by his exposition; and the a-la-mode reviewers are bewildered by the combinations. Nor do I imply that Brinnin is the great modern poet: I mean that he is bringing two poetries together—the lyrical and expositional—and he is not always entirely successful in accepting the double technical responsibilities. Actually, I believe his best work is the lyrical, for image, music and meanings are of one texture. “Shapes in the Shallow Waters” forecasts what Brinnin will be able to achieve in later poetry.

His lyric power depends as much on idiom as on musical structure:

Already have an account? Log in

Join KR for even more to read.

Sign up for a free account and read any five pieces a month.
Sign Up and Read for Free



Or become a subscriber today and get complete, immediate access to our digital archives at every subscription level.

Read More

Another House of God

By Robert Richman

How many skulls, only the gulls   Of Truro will tell, of horseshoe crabs Were tossed by a wide tide's arm, Relentless, restless, the salt sand's care.   Whether crabs are floundered […]

Subscribe

Your free registration with The Kenyon Review includes access to exclusive content, early access to program registration, and more.

Donate

With your support, we’ll continue 
to cultivate talent and publish extraordinary literature from diverse voices around the world.