Church Music: Illusion and Reality by Archibald T. Davison. Harvard University Press. $3.25
For many years A. T. Davison has been admired by students, musicians and music lovers as a performer, author, editor, educator and authority on church music. His latest book exposes the deplorable state of church music in this country at a time when many intellectuals are turning to an appraisal of religion in contemporary life, and it is therefore of interest to more than a specifically musical audience. In accepting Davison’s invitation to disagree with him, as extended in the preface of his book, I shall be guided by a profound respect for his life work and a concern for the musical practices in the Church.
On the surface, the book is highly provocative and entertaining, and there is much one is prone to accept as emphatic statements of fact. A closer reading reveals, however, that its most convincing passages are those of subjective criticism, tinged with sarcasm and invective. As an objective analysis it shows disturbing contradictions and ambiguities, especially in the presentation and development of aesthetic and theological theories. Every thinking church-goer agrees with the thesis that a reform of church music is due, but Davison’s diagnosis of the causes underlying the present condition seems inaccurate and his proposed remedies ineffectual.
A basic ambiguity pervading the book stems from the denial on the one hand that sacred and secular music are intrinsically different, and from the insistence on the other hand that certain sig,nificant musical techniques admissible in the concert hall are inappropriate in church. A listing of devices to be avoided includes sensuous melodiousness, chromaticism, and an over-dose of rhythm; dissonance is criticised as “a sure vehicle of secular emotion” and “only the most sparing and controlled use” is advocated. Here the ambiguity becomes twofold. First, because Davison ignores that the indiscreet use of these elements is distasteful in any kind of music; and second, because it is not a matter of the quantity of certain devices used which places a piece of music in the sacred or secular category. The point Davison constantly overlooks is that the composer’s success in creating a work of art, whether sacred or secular, does not depend on the inclusion or exclusion of certain musical materials, but on the way they are treated.
In his discussion of music expressing humility and confidence, Davison quotes settings of the Kyrie from the Mass. The a cappella polyphonic style of Palestrina is set up as the ideal form for expressing spiritual emotions; examples of the later styles of Lotti, Haydn, Rossini and Liszt are used to illustrate the increasing secularization of church music. It should be noted that among these only Haydn is a major master. One wonders if by considering Schuetz, Purcell, Couperin, Beethoven and Brahms instead, Davison would have been able to come up with his assertion of the general deterioration of church music. The way in which religious and artistic attitudes and values are expressed in a given period forms a complex whole in which all the parts are related. To require that church music be purged of some of the stylistic traits of that period is to refuse the composer the right to be religious on his own terms. After all, how does dissonance distract from humility, rhythm from confidence? The addition, in successive generations, of progressive elements in church music in no wise lessens its spiritual validity, provided the works are representative of the highest musical level of the time.
While it is of course true, as Davison says, that after the Reformation sacred music as we know it split into the Catholic and Protestant branches, it is not correct to say by way of contradistinction that “secular music displays a single thread of purpose throughout.” For a long time, the composer of secular works wrote partly for the entertainment and partly for the edification of his public. Around the middle of the Igth Century, the serious composer, under the pressure of an unprecedented decay of public taste, began to leave the entertainment field to the popular composer. Since that time, most of the cheap music flooding our churches has been written by commercial musicians rather than by creative artists, as has most of the cheap music outside the church. In blaming secularism as such for the abuses due to commercialism, Davison overlooks that the output of any given composer, in both his sacred and secular works, is fairly constant as to quality, whatever that quality may be. Just as the composer of trashy anthems is incapable of writing a decent piano piece, the gifted composer is likely to manage both styles equally well.
No one interested in a spiritually and musically integrated service wants church music to appeal to the lowest artistic instincts by being obvious and sentimental. But to suggest, as Davison does, that music in the church be “a speech apart; remote, archaic perhaps, sacerdotal, strange”; is to turn it into a Sunday-art, something separate from the rest of our life, just as the Psalms are in danger of being turned into a Sunday-beauty and the Gospels into a Sunday-truth. To explain the abundance of commonplace music in the present-day church by declaring somewhat sweepingly that “Our generation is an individualistic and, above all, a realistic one,” makes no sense. Surely, the cliche does not stand for individualism, nor sentimentality for realism. If the impoverished quality of the music we hear in many of our churches is symptomatic of anything, it is symptomatic of the same brand of escapism which motivates the choice and taste of the average consumer of commercial art.
Perhaps the fact that the six chapters are based on lectures delivered as far apart as 1935, 1940 and 1948 explains some of the contradictions in the text, although it does not excuse them. But the book, in spite of its shortcomings, will arouse some of its readers to a renewed or deepened interest in the part music should play in the church service.
