Notes: that is all I am prepared to give, and the fact is strange. Strange, because since the first issue of the Fugitive magazine I have read, I think, every poem of John Crowe Ransom as it appeared, sometimes even in manuscript, and have memorized many of them. Once, some thirty-five years ago, I wrote an essay about them, which, after two or three years, was published. Between that time and this, I have looked back over it only once, and with distaste. Looking back at it again, I am confirmed in an old feeling that the piece did not really indicate the deeper reality I had sensed in the poems. Now that I am invited, for a happy occasion, to write something on John Crowe Ransom, I find that, even today, I do not have the right topic, the name for the thing, whatever the thing may be, that has held me year after year.
There was, however, a period–when I was nineteen to twenty-five years old–when I rebelled against that power exercised by the poems–and exercised, so unwittingly I may add, by their author. It was not merely that I, overwhelmed by the new poetry of Eliot, was puzzled and confused by the coldness of Ransom toward it: puzzled, confused, and at moments outraged, chiefly because of my passion for Ransom’s poetry. Nor was it merely that as I blundered into my own poetry I had to fight off, not always successfully, what William Yandell Elliott, one of the Fugitives, had called “Johnny’s bag of tricks,” as well as T. S. Eliot’s. Nor merely that the very coherence, intellectual and emotional, of Ransom’s poetry was a painful reproach to my own attempts at poetry, which fact I blindly resented. My rebelliousness stemmed, I now suppose, from a resentment against the cast of the author’s mind, a mind which made such graceful gestures, enunciated such deep truths, and exercised such fascinating authority for me, even as I knew, in despair, that I could never emulate that grace, live by those truths, nor accept such authority. My own nature was too volatile, awkward, and angry, and all the harmony and control embodied in the poetry and the man seemed to undercut life-possibility for me and deny life-need.
