Dreams and Resentments
Cello and bassoon. Why do I not like the cello? I can even say I hate it. It is a respectable instrument, sensitive, dignified, profound, manly, grave. It is the instrument of full self-achievement in life. It dominates others and itself to such an extent that it can afford to become suave, melodious, calm, and mild. All this follows, it would seem, from its restrained force. Actually, it is nothing of the kind. For what will happen to all this rounded and controlled manliness in case of real need? How does a cello react when in danger? Can a cello get angry? Who has ever seen an unleashed, raging cello? In such situations, its impotence is ridiculous. True, its polished and oily tone lashes about pathetically, grievously, but it remains pitiable and powerless. A cello is incapable of becoming crazy, heroic, or violent. In fact, it is incapable of humor, too. The cello’s comical range does not go beyond the sociable anecdote, vapid, dull, conformist. The cello has sentimental elegance, is a mature and experienced Don Juan, but without substance; the cello is a prevaricating instrument. Nor is it mendacious out of purposeful wickedness, lying has merely turned into its second nature; lying is its way of being sociable. The cello simulates what other instruments are. Take the bassoon. True enough, the bassoon is boorish, inexperienced, clumsy, stumpy, abrupt; it does not slither around with the false and benevolent smile of the cello, it has none of the noble-syrupy optimism, or the profound-ostentatious suffering of its cousin. On the other hand, it is sincere and straightforward, humorous and unaffected, fair-minded and chivalrously valiant, perhaps a little narrow-minded (none of the broad worldly horizon of the cello), but it is genuine. It may be full of bias and oddities, like an elderly bachelor, but it compensates for this with deep love and generosity (hidden, but real) for its fellow human beings. Hardworking in its way, reserved and simultaneously impulsive, by turns subdued and then boisterous, modest, yet proud; there is one you can rely on when in need. It has courage and knows what duty is. The cello, under a noble and benevolent mask, is sly and treacherous. It is the bassoon, not the cello, that has character.
