Opera: The Extravagant Art by Herbert Lindenberger. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1984. 446 pages. $25.00.
Of all the forms of art, opera often seems the most “in between”; it belongs to its own category, yet it partakes of many other forms as well, resembling musical drama, moving sometimes in the direction of music, other times toward the literary. It is a form that is difficult to define precisely, and its opulence of taste has made its status even more problematic in a century little known for excessive splendor. The strong claims of Herbert Lindenberger’s book, Opera: The Extravagant Art, rest on his turning this problematic status into a virtue, and his work is so masterful because his method is so perfectly suited to his subject matter. As in earlier books, Lindenberger’s approach here depends on multiple perspectives. In comparing opera to musical drama, music, the novel, epic, and tragedy, he manages at once to distinguish these various genres from opera and at the same time to demarcate a very clear space for the luminous qualities of operatic forms. In showing what opera does best, he also reveals the salient qualities of the genres he uses to illuminate it.
