Touching, through its tragic pathos attained by chaste means, pure and shapely as an antique statue, Alceste by Gluck received its first New York performance the evening of January 24th. The need of a novelty, in combination with the circumstance that Orfeo maintains itself in the operatic repertory, fortunately had prompted the Metropolitan once again to revive one of Gluck’s great French operas, and Alceste perfectly had corresponded to the need. Armide had been presented in 1912; Iphigénie en Tauride, in Richard Strauss’s not entirely tasteful arrangement, in 1916. Alceste on the other hand not only had never previously been given in New York: practically it was unknown to America. There is a strong probability that the performance of this “tragedy set to music” in 1938 by the Music Department of Wellesley College under Malcolm Holmes was actually the first American one.
The austere, intensely expressive old work moreover had proffered itself as a vehicle for the anticipated American debut of Mme. Germaine Lubin, a French diva who recently has achieved the noble vocal style demanded by Gluck’s later scores. Deprived of Mme. Lubin by reason of her inability to quit occupied France, the management nevertheless proceeded with the revival, assigning the title role to Mme. Marjorie Lawrence. Its semi-stylized performance had grave faults: chief among them was the unlovely quality of Mime. Lawrence’s tones in the upper registers and their nervous shortcomings in pitch. The ballets aspired to boldness and verged on the ludicrous. The mise-en-scene prevalently recalled AlmaTadema’s pretty visions of antiquity: in the finale the stage-design was pretentiously ugly. Not all the cuts improved the score. But the piece ranks with the royalty of music-dramas; and through the conviction of Mme. Lawrence’s declamation and much of her acting, Leonard Warren’s golden delivery of the music of the High Priest of Apollo, the sincerity of Rene Maison’s Admetus, Ettore Panizza’s precise and glowing direction of the orchestra and choruses, certain happy mimetic details such as the corybantic movements of the priests in the temple-scene, the performance imparted an experience indubitably among the best in grand opera.
