for Polly and Ruth, eyewitnesses
Walter Benjamin, in his seminal essay, “The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction,” has said, “It is inherent in the technique of film as well as that of sports that everybody who witnesses its accomplishments is something of an expert.” Film, like sports, is in essence an act of witnessing, and being an expert is merely giving testimony as to what one has witnessed, something that is theoretically possible for anyone. The recounting and sharing of what one has witnessed, the recapitulation of the seen, forms a large part of the “commentary” on both sports and films. It is precisely this democracy of expertise that makes any attempt at deeper criticism so arbitrary.
