Read the winning piece of our 2025 Nonfiction Contest “Through the Mirror” by Jessie Cato selected by Lucy Ives.

Read

May/June 2021 |

We Sailed on the Lake

We sailed on the lake before the storm

I felt my hair stand on end
I saw this on others

a family in tinfoil hats
weren’t disturbed
by the forecast
of lightning

the water calm
golfers settled into hip sockets
doctor’s orders to keep
synovial joints in motion

each time I asked
is it safe

I ruined everyone’s fun
for fear, my own
I didn’t dare

carry mortality
into deep waters where the gar swim

I wanted to go to shore
I wanted to eat again

we could go shopping
we could take the pig home
and when we did
we found a pencil-thin vein

of meat running through the loin
the rest was fat
to sputter on the grill

we’d been taken by the butcher
who lived
we thought
where fat was good

the dog unhinged
the bone that let his jaw drop
to the floor
the only pose more sad
than death

could you imagine

my friend wished for, on occasion
his pets to disappear

he did so in the name of vacation

between himself and every
imagined afternoon in Mexico
a dog guarded the hallway

he said to me
across the flames
I’m firing blanks

I hadn’t asked how
he was doing

his silver sedan
was red with sunset
and I was fine imagining

we hadn’t begun this
conversation

feels like rain, I said
he said, so no children
for now

it was natural and otherworldly
on the hood of the car
the way only light

can bring an end to itself

rope swing tied
to a hollow branch
no one knew
was hollow

little known lives
beneath bark

we are told not to strip it
to hammer things there
to climb or tie
webbing to its waist

but I don’t mean this
to be another commentary
on what is permitted

we were safe for now
the storm had missed us

a distant road
glimpsed through the trees

the intermittences of travel

flash of an Aldis lamp

was there a game?
a speech on TV?

rain hit the coals
and smoked

evening ceded
its momentum

a friend found the butcher
in the forest picking leaves
from his sweater

the deck altar-like
lit with citronella

my friend tossed his thesis
on the flames
an anthropologist

in awning of light
we played dice over
the body

the game was
roll and roll
until two eyes appear

someone would win
and take the head home
they would make cheese

I was bound to lose

my friend was first son
of Chance
that was his father’s name
he got mileage from this joke
people ate it up

come morning we’d pay
in thankless tasks
of tidying

in the dark
dock joints creaked to their gods

until one bolt
was cast from its bracket
into the reeds

likely lost forever

in its absence
our enterprise
found relief

the fact that jetsam
might save us
was not lost
on the smoke

I wonder how the day would have gone
had we followed instructions

I had almost forgotten
electricity

but suddenly it was there
tickling follicles

a hare sensed we were sated
and dared venture from the penumbra
safe from all
but the owl

we placed a glass bowl
over it
now safe from everything
but the inside

red mountain heather
held some daylight in its bells

if we noticed this
were we not barbarians?

I stabbed the last pickled beet
on my plate

the last green sheep had gone to bed

the butcher buttoned
his black-checked shirt
and fastened his blood-red apron

his moustache was a century old
and more serious than I remembered

he walked off
down the road
because every
single day
work begins

even the sun
makes the same commute

you could believe me
or stay here all day
to follow it

the butcher a mile off now
crying
“she was my queen!”

forgive me

I’m only as human as the last place
I’ve slept

forgive us

when we protect ourselves
in forms
that might appear unloving