Read the winning piece of our 2025 Nonfiction Contest “Through the Mirror” by Jessie Cato selected by Lucy Ives.

Read

May/June 2021 |

Reasonable Accommodation

You’ve met me halfway
between the door to our bedroom
             & the other I doubt

is real only because you
are always gesturing: there it is.
             As if getting to an exit

is as simple as its existence;
as if your body, real or imagined,
             does not make a door

a taunt you can point to
but not touch. You touch me
             like I’m a door

that won’t open. The first fight
ended here, too: my back to the wall
             & your body keeping it

there, every hand & mouth
an act of contrition in an argument
             I was sure I’d misheard

until you were kneeling
to beg me, Stay. Only then
             did I understand yours

was a language of secret
orders & mine a language
             of hidden sounds

you thought you had
to teach me yourself. Tonight
             my shoulders relax

into the dimples they make
in the drywall, the pair of them joining
             the others in repetition

down the hallway, a stampede
through snow. Look at the tracks
             they’ve left, all the animals

my body didn’t mean to be.
Tonight there is no feast. Tonight
             you are only sorry

g-d’s name is the one I choose
to say aloud when you touch me
             like you believe

you could put a door anywhere
if you just push hard enough; like if I
             wasn’t so unreasonable

I could just accommodate
myself; like if it’s so hard, Why don’t you
             just leave
: there it is.

There I am: opening a door
in a wall with a body I should want
             to exit. You touch me

like I’m an animal that needs
correcting. You touch me like it’s for
             my own good.

And wasn’t this my request?
Didn’t I ask you to speak to me
             only with your hands?