My title sounds in these days like a cliché and in all days it is, I think, a tautology; a cliché because for so long now there has been so much talk about Freud and his fellows and their literary uses—a great deal of it talk through an old hat—and a tautology because the novel does not exist that is not psychological, is not concerned with emotional motivations and their intellectual resolutions, with instincts and impulses and conflicts and behavior, with the convolutions and complexities of human relationships, with the crucifixions and the solaces of being alive. I am in danger, to be sure, of keeling over on this tack and saying that all fiction is actually fact, that novels are psychology, and if I should be nothing more for me to say, and in my traumatic embarrassment, be nothing more for me to say and in my traumatic embarrassment, I should be obliged to spend my forthcoming honorarium on a visit to a psychologist who would not, I am very sure, be content with a copy of one of my books as payment of his fee in kind.
But lately we have come to assign a special meaning to the word “psychological” and we use it to label a sort of writing which we distinguish from the “historical” novel or the novel of adventure or of uncomplicated romantic love. It involves a subjective scrutiny of the human heart and mind, usually the author’s own heart and mind, often in a sort of imagined removal from the everyday and active world, and more often than not communicated by a method that is not inhibited by the restrictions of traditional rules. One thinks at once of Proust’s painstaking and loving examination of his past experience, his patient exploration of his relationships with his mother and his grandmother and his lovers and his friends and his servants, and the effect of gardens upon him, and of the sea, and of conversation, and of the remembered taste of tea-cakes. One knows that his diagnostic methods cannot be entirely different from those of the psychoanalyst who rejects no part of his patient’s reflections. Similarly, the stream-of-consciousness of James Joyce resembles the method of free association, and the ordered interior monologue of Mrs. Dalloway, a modification of this. Because Proust is an artist, his novel transcends its technique and is a novel and does not smell of the clinic; but unfortunately few writers can use so subjective a system and remain as objective as he does, and his imitators seem generally to fetch up in a morass of inartistic and embarrassingly personal soul-searching which is not any newer and not any less sentimental than The Sorrows of Werther.
