French existentialism is a complex and, to the critic, a disconcerting product of the European agony. How shall we treat it? As a philosophy in the sense of an attempt at logically ordered discourse which tries to prove something, and hence can be argued with? Or as a kind of metaphysical tone poem, seeking to evoke or express something, and so to be studied as a psychological and sociological phenomenon and to be judged, if judged at all, by aesthetic rather than logical criteria? Some of its critics thus far have adopted one of these strategies and some the other. When viewed as a metaphysical tone poem, Existentialism has come out looking considerably more worthy of respect: one pays obeisance to it as expressing the ethos of the French Resistance, or perhaps more broadly as a cry of pain in the twilight of Western culture, together with a spasmodic heave of expiring life, heroically if frantically voicing against the encroaching atomic or totalitarian night some of the residual values of the Occident, and particularly its aspiration to absolute freedom.
At least the partial appropriateness of such an approach seems evident in the case of Jean-Paul Sartre’s version of Existentialism. Sartre is a novelist and a playwright, a man of the Left Bank and the avant-garde; even his philosophical writings seem of the same epoch as expressionism and surrealism in the arts, and show a community in theme and feeling with the poems of his contemporaries, Michaux, Prévert and Quéneau. If his terminology and what passes for his “logic” are those of Hegel, his rhythms and his syntax are often suggestive of Gertrude Stein. Whether or not the logical positivists are right in holding that metaphysics in general is merely semantic confusion plus emotive utterance, it would appear that in Sartre they have a strong case in point. However Sartre has written not only fiction but books that in form more closely resemble philosophical treatises. His close associate in the development of Existentialism, Maurice Merleau-Ponty, writes a more classic—or at any rate a more conventional—prose, draws more widely than Sartre on history and recent experimental psychology, and uses generally, though not invariably, a logic closer to that of Aristotle and Russell than to that of Hegel and Heidegger.1 It would seem then that a sufficient treatment of Existentialism, which this essay intends at most to suggest, would examine its pretensions to be logical discourse as well as aesthetic expression. When this has been tried—as by A. J. Ayer in Horizon and by Jean Wahl in Deucalion among others—several of the central doctrines of Existentialism have been shown to be extremely vulnerable: the arguments for them are revealed as flimsy paradoxes based on elementary logical fallacies, some of which were perpetrated by Parmenides and Zeno and exposed by Plato in his later writings, even before the birth of systematic logic.
