A Rhetoric of Motives by Kenneth Burke. Prentice Hall. $5.00.
I have often wondered at the intemperate reactions to Mr. Kenneth Burke’s work. A Rhetoric of Motives, to cite the latest instance, has aroused responses ranging from ill-humored scorn, through sheer amusement, to excessive enthusiasm. Of course, Burke has been writing now for almost thirty years and he has devoted the last twenty to the gradual elaboration of a system of theories which embraces many crucial problems. He writes as aesthetician, literary critic, political theorist, political commentator and metaphysician. His subjects are involved with people’s loyalties and passions, and he has made friends and enemies who, though they may not really care to find out what Burke is up to, can catch him at his weakest and strongest moments and distort the rest by omission. The fault is not wholly theirs, however. Burke, with his extraordinary preoccupation with opposition and antitheses, would understand me when I say that his writing is such a strange mixture of sense and nonsense that it is almost impossible to give a coherent discursive account of what he really means. This frustration is probably one of the main reasons for all the immoderate criticisms of his latest book.
