I. “Expressing the Course of the World”
Shakespeare is often a stumbling block and, not infrequently, foolishness or moria. We like to think, for example, that he wrote comedies, histories, and tragedies; yet our neat categories are abrogated—not by himself, it should be emphasized, but by those who superintended his plays for publication—in that Richard II is described in the first quarto of 1597 not as history but as “tragedie,” while Troilus and Cressida is designated as “history” in the quarto of 1609, “comedy” in the address to the reader added in the second state, and “tragedy” in the First Folio.1 True, the critical nomenclature of the Elizabethans and the Jacobeans was, by any civilized standard, crude at best and, at worst, barbarous;2 our own talents being far more creative, we have invented still other categories, notably that of “dark comedies” or, even more generally, of “problem plays.” Polonius would not have disapproved.
