It has long been recognized that the writing of the century’s premier prose fictionist is largely indifferent to the interests of “story,” action, plot, events, things happening. Joyce acknowledged as much himself, in his last, most unreadable book, when Shaun the Post, fuming in behalf of common-reader values (“the whacker his word the weaker our ears”), indicts his highbrow, Joyce-like brother Shem the Penman for his “sin against the past participle” (Finnegans Wake, p. 467),1 that is, against the sine qua non of narrative. Joyce is the least narrative of novelists, so much so that it is arguable whether he is a “novelist” at all. His first literary efforts were with the short, songlike lyric, and when the conventional constraints of that genre became too confining he moved into prose with the “epiphany,” a nonnarrative genre more or less his own, registering a sudden heightened awareness, a moment of revelation, seemingly discontinuous with the rest of time, that is, with any “narrative” that might enmesh it in a fixed sequence of what-came-before and what-came-after. Dubliners, the Portrait, and Ulysses can all be regarded as fictions that circumvent narrative, variously contriving extranarrative means to present, so to speak, the cruxes of the story without the story, the revelatory moments, the epiphanies, that clearly interest Joyce more; and in Finnegans Wake, narrative and character reduce to myths and archetypes so generalized and stylized as to subsume all possible stories and all possible roles instantaneously: roles, apprehended as archetypes, already disclose all possible plots in which they might figure; plots, apprehended as myths, are already foreknown in all essentials of character and event. (Whether, in Joyce, this imports most for “language” or for “life,” or whether the two are “ultimately” separable, are questions that apparently seem much more agitating to me than to most other readers of Joyce.)
From the very beginning, Joyce appears to have regarded “narrative” as the Achilles’ heel of fiction, a sort of original generic flaw. Stanislaus Joyce reports his brother’s early contempt for “plotty” fiction: he “came to consider a well-ordered plot in a novel or story as a meretricious literary interest, like the story in a tableau de genre.”2 Throughout his life, Joyce’s reported remarks about other novelists usually attack, precisely, their plots as implausible and unbelievable. Joyce’s rigorously “realist” sensibility denigrates plot, story, narrative, not only as a cheap affective interest, but as dishonest, as “make-believe.” He regards the kinesis of narrative as not the proper medium for the representation of reality, preferring instead the stasis of image.
