Across the River and Into the Trees by Ernest Hemingway. Scribner’s. $3.00.
It is not enough to say that Across the River and Into the Trees is a bad novel, which nearly everyone has said (the fact is, a good deal of it is trash), or to ascribe its failure to Hemingway’s playing Hemingway. Such judgments fail to go deep; they make an artificial separation between the man and the artist, and attribute to the former, as though these were superficial mistakes, shortcomings which are the very essence of Hemingway’s art. It seems to me that no writer of comparable stature has ever expressed in his work so false an attitude toward life. Now this is more than a matter of temperament, though the pompous boasting, the sounding off on life, love and literature in baseball, prize-ring and military metaphors (the purpose of which is to demonstrate that Hemingway is so great a literary figure that he is primarily an athlete, a hunter, a soldier, a lover of fine wines and women—anything but a writer; this is what I consider trash) that run all through this book, do help to create the impression that Hemingway has gone on a bender and deserted his art. But these monkeyshines are defenses, and to ignore the serious principle while criticizing Hemingway’s legend of himself is to succumb to the strategy: at the expense of the man, to flatter the art.
