Stephen Crane, An Omnibus, selected and edited with critical introductions and notes by Robert Wooster Stallman. Knopf. $5.00.
Since much of Stephen Crane’s work is hard to come by, any good collection—and this certainly is one—deserves to be commended. Maggie and The Red Badge of Courage have been available for quite a while; but as Mr. Stallman’s is a critical anthology and therefore bound to publish the author’s best work, the inclusion of the two novels is justified. Moreover, the present edition of The Red Badge is likely to stand as the definitive one, as it is based on a study of the various manuscripts, the typescript and the printed versions, with variant readings for many passages and a good number of words and lines restored where there was no reason to believe that Crane wanted them deleted. There is another short novel, George’s Mother, which it seems to me Mr. Stallman overrates. The stories are liberally represented with “The Open Boat” (in the editor’s judgment this story, together with The Red Badge, makes up Crane’s masterwork), “The Blue Hotel,” “The Bride Comes to Yellow Sky,” and some lesser stories and sketches about war, children and Bowery life. The poems are shown in a meagre and reluctant sample, Mr. Stallman being of uncertain mind about their value, though he does assign to them a high historical importance. There is also a large number of letters and a bibliography. Every anthology is forced to leave out something; but I should say that the only regrettable omission in the present one is The Monster. This is then a very satisfactory collection.
