This study of Nietzsche and Rilke, and particularly of what they have in common, is meant to throw light on both and also on the relation of philosophy and poetry. To those who are used to comparisons of Nietzsche with Nero and of Rilke with St. Francis any insistence on common elements will come as a surprise; but it may also disabuse them of some misapprehensions. There are, of course, obvious differences between the two men; and it is unlikely that an extended contrast would prove illuminating. Some reflection on what they have in common, on the other hand, may help us more to understand the relation of poetry to philosophy than the customary juxtaposition of Dante and St. Thomas—as atypical a pair as one is likely to find: Thomas, with his dogmatic commitments, is utterly unlike any Greek or modern philosopher; the Divine Comedy is unlike any other poem; and Dante’s relation to Thomas is unlike that of any other major poet and philosopher. Shakespeare and Seneca, whom T. S. Eliot juxtaposes not without sarcasm, could hardly be more disparate—in time, stature, or sensibility. Nietzsche and Rilke, on the other hand, furnish a nearly ideal pair. Probably they are, respectively, the greatest German philosopher and poet of the last hundred years: they wrote in the same language and belong roughly to the same age.
Two further facts make it strange that comparisons have not become a commonplace long ago, especially in view of the vast literature that has accumulated around both men. First, Nietzsche’s influence is very apparent, if as yet very ill digested, in some of Rilke’s juvenilia. And secondly, both men loved the same woman—probably more than any other. Nietzsche loved Lou Salomé in 1882 when she was barely over twenty, and she listened to his innermost ideas without quite reciprocating his feelings. Their relation was short-lived but intense, and their break and Nietzsche’s subsequent solitude precipitated his first attempt to develop his whole philosophy in a single major work, his Zarathustra. When Rilke met her fifteen years later, in 1897, Nietzsche was slowly dying; he was known the world over; Lou herself had recently published a book about him; and she was mature while Rilke, at twenty-two, was not. She was married to Professor Andreas but became Rilke’s mistress, traveled with him, and their love was complete.
