Dynamics Of Art by Andrew Paul Ushenko. Indiana University Press. $3.75.
In his attack on materialism and atheism, Bishop Berkeley used an excellent stratagem: he cleared the field of space. This is putting it paradoxically, but without real contradiction. What he cleared the field of is what we now call physical space, which is a good way to get rid of physical objects as independent external mechanisms; but that this still left a domain of a sort for motion of a sort is evidenced by his afterwards saying that we “live, move, and have our being” in it. Descartes’ previous idea of mind as non-extended substance, taken over by Berkeley, makes the notion of a physically non-extended but nevertheless voluminous field delicate. But the concept is fundamental, and one avoids it at his own risk. Berkeley implicitly toyed with this large category of “field,” in which physical space is an abstraction. Mr. Ushenko, as we shall see, does not try to by-pass the commodious metaphysical concept of “field.” He wisely embraces and develops it, without the usual reduction to physical space as the only objective region, as if volume in any larger sense involves metaphor.
