It is now generally recognized that Absalom, Absalom! consists of several interrelated attempts to make sense out of the past, that none of these attempts is definitive, and that the contorted, jungle-like style so offensive to Clifton Fadiman is an essential counterpart to the search for meaning and certainty undertaken by the characters. Yet, none of the interpretations of the novel thus far offered pursues the implications of these statements. If none of the narrators reports reliably, we cannot use their analyses of events as clues to Faulkner’s own attitude toward the past and the South. Each successive insight provides us with crucial information about the narrator who is offering it, but every addition to our knowledge of the Sutpen legend only gives further proof that it is impossible to interpret human experience objectively, to draw conclusions from it that will be valid for anyone but the speaker and interpreter of the moment.
Faulkner dramatizes on every page the futility of imposing any kind of order or pattern upon human life, while at the same time revealing with the utmost compassion, and making us feel with the greatest poignancy, that the yearning to make logical sense out of events is a compulsive, inescapable need, one of the defining characteristics of the human soul. More than this, while he takes great pains to remind us that the narrators’ interpretations are unreliable and wholly subjective, and while a close study of his text will lead the reader to total skepticism, Faulkner has constructed the novel with such extraordinary skill that our disbelief is almost wholly suspended as we read it for the first time. His daring and brilliant strategy in Absalom, Absalom! is to divide us against ourselves, our emotional against our intellectual responses, by providing us with continually more irresistible and subtle rhetorical arguments until we forget what we have been asked to take on faith and what we can safely accept as known and proven. Faulkner plays upon precisely those needs and desires in us that he shows operating in his characters, and demonstrates the truth of his fable by making us equally blind and hopeful participants in the search for illumination. He knows which springs to touch in us at which moment; we respond with increasing eagerness to the successive accounts of his characters because each new interpretation appeals more to our innate trust that human experience not only can be understood but will be found to accord with the laws and precepts of logic and morality that we like to believe govern our lives, though we might have trouble actually demonstrating their prominence. Yet, a dispassionate, analytical review of the novel’s structure should demonstrate that far from clarifying the original subjects of concern and uncertainty, the different revelations actually obscure the facts of Sutpen’s life and hinder the reader from evaluating their significance.
