As a condition of freedom and progress in intellectual pursuits, the great American philosopher Charles Peirce issued the recommendation: “Do not block the way of inquiry.” With this advice his fellow pragmatists William James and John Dewey were fully in accord. Responsive to the technical sense in which Peirce understood the notion of inquiry, Dewey carefully elaborated the idea into a comprehensive theory of the intelligent control of experience.
Along somewhat different but still related lines, William James set forth a philosophy of pluralism in which the variety and immediacy of experience are primary and authentic traits and growth and novelty are genuine features of existence. One year before his death in 1910 he wrote, “I think the center of my whole Anschauung, since years ago when I read Renouvier, has been the belief that something is doing in the universe, and that novelty is real.”1 His mention of Renouvier is revealing; coming at the end of a philosophic lifetime, it is a reflection upon its philosophic beginning. For in 1869-70 James underwent a crisis in which he felt impelled to suicide or madness. In the work of Renouvier, especially on the freedom of the will, he found a resolution of his despair and the way to health. This experience of purposelessness and panic and acutely sensed futility in a universe viewed as alien to individual human concerns and aspirations in the disposition of fatefully coercive and meaningless forces, and the eventual struggle to regain stability and “‘passionate initiative” (as he put it), was to find a permanent place in James’s later philosophical analysis of the power and function of belief. In his private record of the crisis, he remarked that whereas suicide had appeared as the most daring and manly affirmation, “now, I will go a step further with my will, not only act with it, but believe as well; believe in my individual reality and creative power.”2
