Proust read Bergson, then he wrote his poem.
I thought if I read Bergson too I’d figure out a way
To say what I’ve been gesturing at all my life
Without success: la durée, duration, time,
My own time, by which I mean your own time too.
I don’t know why: the days go by without event,
Resembling one another in the main and in the details,
Each remaining utterly individual in its moment
As it disappears. The gray day dawns and turns to snow
Accumulating on the cars and on the parking lot
Below my window, other cars roll by along the street
I can see from my desk, while Henri Bergson floats adrift
On confusions about quantity and quality, and I—
I go on reading. Chapter Two: riflings about numbers
By a man who gave up mathematics for philosophy
Too soon, and missed what they’d discovered—
Numbers aren’t constructed out of space or human time,
But from a pure idea of order at some Key West of the mind
Beyond duration and experience, where they last forever.
It’s a great idea, yet we live in time, and here Bergson is right:
Each moment represents a whole—a whole of what?
It’s There I start to lose him, as he wonders off into peculiar notions
Of succession, space and time—I want to throw his book against the
Wall as Wittgenstein said he wanted to whenever he read Hume.
The whole has got to be a life, an ordinary, individual life,
A singular existence rounded with a sleep, contained in its entirety
In every moment, like a pageant bathing in the light of an eternal now.
Sometimes I don’t believe a word I say, and then remember why:
I think that everyone’s as vexed by time as I am, and because I do
I grab whatever rhetoric comes my way. Of course there’s
Something to be said for reticence and tact, but also something to be
Said for passionate abstraction, and for letting contradictions flow
Before relaxing back into reflection and the present tense
And nothing new to say. The poetry of life feels inexhaustible,
But it advances haltingly, besieged by second thoughts
And doubts—basking in the present, then returning to the past
For substance; wandering out into the open, then retreating
Back into the soul’s small room; while all the while
Attempting to articulate a single thought constructed out of
Two opposing ones: that life is little; and that life is all.
