Even a fairly satisfactory Broadway season produces few original American plays worth any consideration. In examining this season’s list, we can safely eliminate most of the plays winnowed away by public disfavor, as well as the popular jokebook comedies (Season in the Sun) and the soap-operas trying hard to be problem plays (Hilda Crane). That leaves only Clifford Odets’ The Country Girl, Tennessee Williams’ The Rose Tattoo, Lillian Hellman’s The Autumn Garden, and Edmund Wilson’s The Little Blue Light.
By making the acting profession one of its chief concerns, The Country Girl invites comparison with two well-worn comedies of theatrical life that were revived this season, Twentieth Century and The Royal Family. The themes of these plays have a superficial resemblance: we love the theatre more than bourgeois respectability (The Royal Family), more than Hollywood gold (Twentieth Century), more than romance and personal happiness (The Country Girl). But, unlike the revivals, The Country Girl deserves credit for making some effort at verisimilitude, for taking its people seriously.
