Read the winning piece of our 2025 Nonfiction Contest “Through the Mirror” by Jessie Cato selected by Lucy Ives.

Read

Summer 1951 • Vol. XIII No. 3 • Nonfiction |

Madame Bovary: Beauty out of Place

Whatever Madame Bovary may be in the history of the development of the European Novel, or of French sensibility, or of Flaubert’s genius, it has as the author says m his dedication “an unexpected authority” of its own. Into that authority, not so much unexpected as beyond expectations, these remarks propose to enquire. It is a novel which is the shape of a life which is the shape of a woman which is the shape of a desire. It is one of those structures of the imagination where we can count on sexual force to fill up all the hollow places, and it is such a structure seen in one of those situations where we may expect the force to be taken as a sentiment and where, at critical junctures, the sentiment will be taken for a force. Somewhere among these shapes, structures, and situations the theme finds itself. Everything goes towards the theme, and “all” the theme does is to pull everything together. It is that pulling together which is the theme. Depending on whether we think of the book as an object in art or of the uses to which we put the book we include the theme by calling it Emma Bovary or Bovarysme. It is either the history of Emma so reaching for a passion that the act of reaching was itself a passion; or it is the moving, receptive symbol of the tendency, the need, the drive in each of us so to overreach ourselves that we hang on for dear life—so to speak in order to live at all—to the image of what is other than we are. The passion of the reach becomes the compassion of the symbol. To put it again, it is the history of one of the great ways by which we accommodate our inner or our true selves to the bruise and press of society. It is nothing so simple as escape. It is something Dmitri Karamazov had in mind when he said that the immense mass of mankind could find beauty only in Sodom. It is also the history of that kind of damnation which comes when we are unable to accept the conditions of life; a damnation in which the indifferent rejoice; but a damnation which to those conscious of the beauty that is actually being damned becomes tragedy: the tragedy of long perspective.

The imagination which Flaubert could not help bringing to his history (the very perspective of his personal vision) is what transforms the mere beauty and the mere human damnation into tragedy. Perhaps the sentiment of some such power in Flaubert was what made Henry James record of him in an early notebook that he was “tender, manly, deeply corrupted, but uncorrupting.” This is a way of getting at the objective imagination—what Flaubert is generally assumed to have had. When it is imagination, there is nothing so personal, nothing so capable of receiving the personal, as objective expression. Being objective it is created, it comes into existence. Its very objectiveness both keeps out some of the illusions that go with our predilections of personality and liberates into our expression a great deal of our actual experience for which our predilections had no form. It liberates images: all the things that being their own meaning gather meaning unto themselves. Who can tell what an image will be up to next? Who can tell what will happen, once an image gets going under the level at which we have convictions and careers yet illuminating both, telling us what convictions are made of and what careers come up against? Here piety comes in through the window—breaking glass.

Already have an account? Log in

Join KR for even more to read.

Sign up for a free account and read any five pieces a month.
Sign Up and Read for Free



Or become a subscriber today and get complete, immediate access to our digital archives at every subscription level.

Read More

Upcoming
Workshops

Subscribe

Your free registration with The Kenyon Review includes access to exclusive content, early access to program registration, and more.

Donate

With your support, we’ll continue 
to cultivate talent and publish extraordinary literature from diverse voices around the world.