What is a literary period? The more one broods on this old familiar concept, the odder it seems. The very word “period”—derived from the Greek peri (round) plus hodos (a way)— implies circumference, limitation, arbitrary boundaries, and suggests, therefore, that those who find themselves in the wrong place at the wrong time might not definitively belong to any period at all. More than ten years ago, J. Hillis Miller elegantly summarized some of the key issues raised by our recurrent use of the conventional concept “literary period.” “The problematic of periodization,” he wrote, “is a particularly complex form of the problematic of naming. . . . Does literary history exist, in the sense of an orderly narrative and causal sequence, readable, comprehensible by the imaginative reason? Or is it no more than a vast shifting fabrication, made up after the fact by historians?” and he added, “The problematic of period names includes the following issues . . . : Who has the right to name the period? … Does the name of a period indicate its intrinsic essence . . . or is it a convenient fiction?”‘
Obviously, because women are so often among those who find themselves in the wrong place at the wrong time, feminist cultural historians have also been meditating on these matters for some years, challenging what had long seemed a virtually inalienable male “right to name the period” and to define its “intrinsic essence” in terms of masculine activities. In the early seventies Joan Kelly-Gadol observed in her groundbreaking essay “Did Women Have a Renaissance?” that “one of the tasks of women’s history is to call into question accepted schemes of periodization.”2 And indeed, the work of a number of recent feminist theorists sometimes seems to interrogate not only “accepted schemes of periodization” but the very concept of periodization in and of itself. Do women have periods—the kind we study in school? Or has “the problematic of naming” deformed and defaced female literary history? Further, is there a relationship between the apparent coherence of a period and its sexual politics?
