Well over 400 applications whizzed electronically into our offices during the winter, each in hope of capturing a new Kenyon Review Fellowship. I confess to feeling somewhat overwhelmed. Almost all of the applicants were qualified; half were strong candidates; about 100 were dazzling. We winnowed toward a dozen individuals for interviews in Chicago. Four visited Gambier to teach a sample class and present a reading of their work. And two remarkable writers and teachers have, ultimately, been awarded two-year fellowships.
The principal criterion in the selection process was the quality, achievement, and promise of the work. Many applications offered glimpses of great promise, yet we sensed that the authors had not quite come into their own as yet. Equally, many candidates seemed perhaps too far along already, having published more than one book and been honored with other grants and fellowships—for them ours would be merely another stud on the belt, an honor but not an essential step forward in their career.
