Viscount Bolingbroke, Tory Humanist by Jeffrey Hart. University of Toronto Press, $5.00.
Statesmanship And Party Government: A Study of Burke and Bolingbroke by Harvey C. Mansfield, Jr. University of Chicago Press, $7.50.
More penetrating criticism of Edmund Burke has been published in the past fifteen years than in the whole preceding century; and Burke’s influence upon political thought—indeed, even upon political action—is stronger than it has been since the first quarter of the nineteenth century. Now, after a longer period of neglect, Henry St. John, Lord Bolingbroke, is being scrutinized by men of letters and men of political theory.
“Who now reads Bolingbroke?” Burke demanded. Burke’s own early satire, A Vindication of Natural Society, had overwhelmed Boingbroke’s vindication of “natural” religion; one was a great Tory, the other a great Whig; and their private characters were very different. Yet Mr. Hart and Mr. Mansfield link their names, despite these strong distinctions, for Bolingbroke and Burke were concerned with the same enduring questions.
Both these able studies have for their theme the character of political leadership. Mr. Hart describes Bolingbroke’s endeavor to realize or to retain in the eighteenth century the humanist model of the great men of virtue and ability, rising above faction to regenerate the commonwealth. Against Bolingbroke’s design for a government or an opposition led by grand patriotic gentlemen, Mr. Mansfield sets the alternative of Burke—that is, politics conducted by well-organized prudential parties. Both Bolingbroke’s and Burke’s undertakings were conservative (despite Mansfield’s somewhat labored dissent as to Burke); both leaders understood the hard necessities of the dawning age; and both were rhetoricians of a high power.
Jeffrey Hart, one of the best scholarly writers of this decade, commences his book with a description of Melozzo da Forli’s painting (now at Windsor) of the Duke of Urbino and his household listening to a grave humanist. Here is Bolingbroke’s archetype—the humane philosopher instructing prince, ecclesiastic, and courtier. St. John stood in the tradition of Erasmus, More, and Colet; with Sir Thomas Elyot, he intended that the governors of the nation should be strong men of humane learning and aristocratic virtue.
Erasmus, it is true, had doubted whether the humanist should stoop to practical politics: his views were those of “Raphael Hythlodaye,” in More’s Utopia. But the English humanists were agreed that the gentlemen of humane learning must be imbued with a Roman willingness to direct the affairs of the realm. Thus Mr. Hart puts it:
