Read the winning piece of our 2025 Nonfiction Contest “Through the Mirror” by Jessie Cato selected by Lucy Ives.

Read

Summer 1966 • Vol. XXVIII No. 3 • Book Reviews |

Unhappy Dozen

The Uncommitted: Alienated Youth in American Society by Kenneth Keniston. Harcourt, Brace and World, $8.50.

Here is a highly original study of a phenomenon visible to any experienced college teacher: the puzzling disaffection of some of his most talented pupils. Especially at our very best institutions, these young people, easily capable of mastering the college curriculum, apparently well-launched on the educational high road to lucrative careers in the professions or the corporations, instead involve themselves bizarrely, almost suicidally in drug experiments, beatnik styles of life, extremist political activity. even crusades in favor of four-letter words. If one is a generation older, it is not always simple to grasp why these children of good fortune discover satisfaction neither in selfish careerism nor in the traditional utopian goals of radical politics; why their experiments in the exploration of the self yield them so little gratification; why indeed neither the world of intellect nor the universe of sentiment seems to diminish a deep unhappiness with themselves, other people, and the world.

Keniston’s explanation draws upon both psychiatry and sociology. Working at Harvard, he selected a sample of highly alienated undergraduates, twelve in all. Over a three-year period, Keniston and his helpers conferred with their unhappy dozen, evoked written autobiographies, and isolated the common elements of these students’ childhood and adolescence. In the early lives of this group the most powerful force was a strong. discontented mother—a woman who, usually with some justification, believed that her marriage had prevented the complete fulfilment of her ambitions and aspirations. The wives either dominated their mates or forced them into withdrawing from any active role in their own families. Whether they were financial failures or not, the fathers were perceived by their wives as men who had abandoned their goals and settled for inferior objectives.

Thus far this is a tale told by Freud. And up to a point the sequel, as Keniston recounts it, is simply an extension of the Oedipal drama. The frustrated mothers center their love, their hopes, and their demands upon the sons. The sons, deprived of the strong masculine model that an effective father might have offered them, encounter severe difficulty in loosing themselves from their mothers. From such unpromising origins the full genitality of the uncomplicated adult is unlikely to emerge. All the same, since these young men are exceptionally intelligent, they function well enough to secure Harvard admission. This success only momentarily disguises a wounded psyche. The confusion of their sexual natures (a gift from mother) is accompanied by deep suspicion of the worthiness of gainful employment (a legacy from a failed father). Thus, even though they keep out of academic trouble, these twelve youngsters encounter nothing at Harvard which releases their emotions, identifies an acceptable vocation, or reconciles them to their own prospects in life. Deeply suspicious of persons and causes, scornful of ideologies, dangerously close to solipsism in their near disbelief in the validity of other people’s experiences, they retreat into dismal, isolated worlds of their own construction.

For most of these Harvard undergraduates, the orthodox Freudian would not hesitate to recommend full-scale psychoanalysis. After all, these are highly gifted, unusually verbal analysands evidently afflicted by unresolved Oedipal conflicts. Better candidates for the couch could scarcely be imagined. Nor does Keniston oppose analysis as such. But he judges that it is too easy and too complacent an answer for the community to return to its disturbed children. Accordingly, the second and longer portion of this volume is an attempt to demonstrate that contemporary alienation is insufficiently explained in orthodox Freudian categories. Keniston’s claim is simple and large: our technological society contains within it the stuff to alienate all of us, for ours is a society which separates feeling and cognition, deeply splits the personality, and drains out of individual action any sense of individual achievement. In one of his statements of this position, Keniston puts the issue in these words:


What our society lacks, then, is a vision of itself and of man that transcends technology. It exacts a heavy human toll not because technology exists, but because we allow technology to reign. It alienates so many not simply because they do not share its wealth, but because its wealth includes few deeply human purposes. It is a society that too often discourages human wholeness and integrity, too frequently divides men from the best parts of themselves, too rarely provides objects worthy of commitment.


The illuminating way to interpret the behavior of alienated, uncommitted collegians is as criticism of a society which insufficiently challenges, enlists, and rewards its new recruits. To their credit, the alienated are different from the rest of us: their society affronts them more than it does us, their individual psychological traumas are more severe, and the interaction of the social and the personal is more disruptive for them than for most just because they are highly gifted and unusually sensitive human beings. We can learn from the alienated a good deal both about the unalienated and the society within which both groups must somehow function.

How valid is Keniston’s interpretation of his evidence? Certainly anyone rooted in Freud and stimulated by Riesman and Erikson will find Keniston’s position immediately appealing. Among the middle-aged in academia it is not uncommon to identify a yearning for alienation which may have replaced past mature yearnings for lost radicalism. I share the years, I recognize the attractions of the attitude, and I should like to accept Keniston as my guide.

But doubt does creep in. There is, to begin with, the striking omission of half the human race. Keniston’s entirely male group is centered upon mother-son relations and male vocational dissatisfactions. Now, I do not mean to charge Keniston with misdemeanors graver than any he has committed. He neither denies nor affirms the possibility of feminine alienation. Nevertheless, the lacuna in his argument is substantial, for unless he or someone else can establish as serious a case for the prevalence of alienation among young women as among young men, all his generalizations are 50 percent reduced in their scope. Moreover, if it turns out that our society is reasonably satisfying for women, the social therapies required will substantially differ from those justified by a society unsatisfactory to both sexes, for much the same reasons.

But, even when one focuses upon men only, it is hard to believe that Keniston has really demonstrated an important proposition, the greater alienation that a technological society produces. Although his pages are dotted with unsupported and unverifiable comparisons between technological societies of the present and better societies of the past, no general argument really proves that our society produces more alienation than, say, England during the Industrial Revolution, Russia under the Czars, or the Great Plains under the rule of the Sioux. And sometimes such evidence as is offered is simply unconvincing. Does American society really repress the instincts with unprecedented efficiency? Well, the declining age of marriage and the spread of premarital sexual intercourse do suggest that one instinct at the least is getting more chance than it did a generation ago. Is it true that anger and hostility are suppressed by the demands for rational control in large business and technical organizations? Maybe, but it is just possible that competitive sports, never more popular, give either direct or vicarious outlets to this instinct as well.

My reaction amounts to this: I agree with Keniston that ours is a defective society. I even agree that its defects are of a variety likely to trouble the talented and the imaginative. His analysis of his chosen dozen has all the fascination of good case studies. Nevertheless, in the end I think that Keniston has failed to identify the necessary connection between corrupt society and alienated individuals, between social defect and diagnosed neurosis which, unfortunately, was the object of the entire exercise. At the risk of seeming old-fashioned, I can’t help but say that these students in all likelihood would benefit from a responsible Freudian analysis.

The students are ill. It is undemonstrated that society is the villain. For society is always sick and the intelligent and the idealistic always face uncomfortable choices when they treat with the social devil. The time-servers will accept the rule and do their best to maximize personal advantage. Others will retreat into family life or personal recreations, without the repinings that must follow such a choice according to Keniston. Some will try to alter their society. And others will be alienated, but whether more or fewer than in the past we simply do not know. Since Keniston never demonstrates that choice in the present is less real than in the past, he fails to prove that the malaise of his Harvard undergraduates is social as well as personal. 

Already have an account? Log in

Join KR for even more to read.

Sign up for a free account and read any five pieces a month.
Sign Up and Read for Free



Or become a subscriber today and get complete, immediate access to our digital archives at every subscription level.

Read More

Shivery Games

By Sheridan Baker

Trials Of The Word: Essays in American Literature and the Humanistic Tradition by R. W. B. Lewis. Yale University Press, $6.50. These essays prove Mr. Lewis a more saintly perambulator […]

Subscribe

Your free registration with The Kenyon Review includes access to exclusive content, early access to program registration, and more.

Donate

With your support, we’ll continue 
to cultivate talent and publish extraordinary literature from diverse voices around the world.