Modern Poetry: A Personal Essay. By Louis MacNeice. Oxford. $3.00
Mr. MacNeice’s matter is more personal than his manner, which is highly unindividual; the straightforward, general, elevating tone, varied judiciously with jokes or pieces of slang, the reassuringly commonplace analogies, the frequent little guidebook summaries, the general air of more or less talking down, of goodhumoredly and sensibly overlooking any unprofitable or embarrassing complications, make his book remind you of one of those endowed series of lectures by some prominent physicist, who also gets you to accept what he knows by putting it simply, what he believes by putting it inspiringly. (Sometimes Mr. MacNeice does worse, and his sentences have a haunting ring of the Scout’s Handbook: for instance, when he decides that rhyme is desirable because it presents a “healthy technical problem,” or that writing light lyrics for music is a “healthy” occupation.) He writes an efficient undifferentiated prose, without much strength or possibility of emotion, but with a disquieting tropism for obvious wordings: in his prose the ballads have “a savour of the earth,” and there are loungelizards and highbrows and physiques and “tortured but vital personalities” and verse “memorable for its music” and “forces which make for progress” and “honest surveys” and “unflinching recognitions”—things one hardly expected from the author of Bagpipe Music. His book is full of truisms you consent to without much pleasure, and half-truths you dissent from without much heat; so that you end by observing everything with sleepy enjoyment, like H. G. Wells reflecting that somehow Reason always does muddle through.
