A leader, Mr. Eliot stated in one of his Criterion Commentaries, may be defined as that one of the Gadarene swine which runs the fastest. Mr. Eliot may have had a Fuehrer in mind, or at any rate, a politician; and Hart Crane, when in a letter to Otto Kahn he spoke of the editor of The Criterion as a director, used an unfamiliar but exact term. Mr. Eliot was not a leader of his generation or of his magazine. He was an editor, and by this is meant, I think, a being distinct in kind from poet and critic, professions in which Mr. Eliot was engaged also.
An editor must demand of his contributors such qualities as intelligence, honesty, learning, seriousness, and a relevant concern with the problems of the age. Obviously Mr. Eliot permitted his interests as poet and critic to suggest much to him, and there are occasions, though they are rare, when his interests did not improve the magazine. But he did not use The Criterion as an instrument with which to further any ends which are distinct from that of an editor’s. And the vices which few editors avoid —such as the pleasure of agreement, the flattery of imitation, the over-niceness of not permitting one’s own name as poet to appear in one’s magazine— were avoided. What we get when we look through the seventeen bound volumes is a kind of charity of the intellect, and this issues, one must remember, from one who maintained that excessive tolerance is to be deprecated. The distinction between charity, as practiced in The Criterion, and tolerance, is perhaps obscure; but one can scarcely doubt that Mr. Eliot tolerated judgements, views, and concerns, which, his editorship apart, he could at the very best have regarded as the intelligent statement of error and of heresy.
