Creation And Discovery, Essays In Criticism And Aesthetics by Eliseo Vivas. Noonday Press. $5.00.
In his previous book, The Moral Life and the Ethical Life, Eliseo Vivas announced to the world his break with the whole naturalistic and humanistic tradition with which his work as a philosopher had hitherto been identified. Not only his ideas, but the focus of his philosophical attention and the very texture of his discourse were now altered beyond recognition. Vivas’ prose had always been lively; he was one of the few American philosophers who permitted his temperament to emerge in his writing. But “lively” is hardly the word for his new manner. I was therefore somewhat surprised, when I opened his new book, to find sandwiched in among essays that represent his “more mature” thought on aesthetics a number of papers belonging to his old, unregenerate phase, and I was interested to see how he would reconcile his old talk about the aesthetic experience as an “intransitive” attention to “presentational immediacies” with his new talk about art as a revelation of “value traits” splendidly subsistent in rerum natura. No doubt the thing could be done, words being what they are; the question was, how? I think Vivas’ success in this respect is indifferent; certain verbal substitutions have been made to give the presented immediacies a grander ontological status, but he has still not succeeded in showing how a work of art can be aesthetically pure, in his sense, and yet also be a porch from which we may view realms of being to which the more discursive understanding has no access. There is still the same old dissociation between the aesthetic and the meaningful, between aesthesis and cognition, and the same old rigid bifurcation between “referential meaning” and whatever it is that we apprehend through words when we try to read aesthetically. But Vivas’ new philosophy puts his aesthetics on the stretch, and in the end something will have to give. It is this fact which gives his book its interest and which makes it a kind of paradigm of the predicament of contemporary aesthetics and critical theory.
