The Structure Of Literature by Paul Goodman. University of Chicago Press. $5.00.
Paul Goodman has most of the powers which both contemporary literature and the modern conception of an adequate reading of any literature have come to demand of the critic: psychological insight, breadth of culture, philosophical acumen, the gift of tongues, the artist’s formal sense and respect for the uniqueness of a work of art. His only serious weakness would seem to be an absence of style. By this I mean not just that he has very little of the grace and wit that make Johnson or Santayana or Forster so delightful to read on their own account, but also that he is deficient in the qualities of clarity, order, and continuity which are indispensable to the performance of any critic’s job of work. Goodman’s writing has its flashes of compression and directness; but it is frequently slack or high-handed, and too often leaves an impression of impatience with the task at hand. There is also an odd, academic pretentiousness which ironically deflates the intelligence and sensibility into miscellaneous aperçus. If this were table talk, we might simply accept the gift, disregarding the remainder as hiatus. As it is, Goodman’s critical claims are so insistently pressed that we are obliged to take him at his word and judge his achievement in their terms.
