Living with Ballads by Willa Muir. Oxford University Press, $5.75.
Mrs. Muir’s Living with Ballads begins delightfully with “Children’s Singing Games” in her native small town on the northeast coast of Scotland. The year is 1901, the arena variously an enclosed school-yard or the road outside, a farm-laborer’s bothy (a kind of bunk-house), or the smooth level opening-out at a crossroads where the children could dance and sing without danger of motorcars or molesters. Clearly, this is a golden reminiscence of a golden age now quite gone by, and it is Mrs. Muir’s declared aim to reveal the deep satisfactions that such living with ballads has given to simple country people for hundreds of years past. In general, her method is to exemplify by one or two ballads what she considers to be the successive stages in the historical evolution of folk sensibility from the medieval culture (feudal practices are said to have persisted in northeast Scotland until the eighteenth century) through the Reformation, the Age of Reason, and the Romantic Reaction, to the near present. When Mrs. Muir turns to Homer and the Gilgamesh for background, and pursues vestiges of matriarchal and pagan cultures in the ballad proper, the influence of a developing self-consciousness, of literacy, Calvinism, and the decline of family authority, the rise of romantic love, sentimentality, and the self-dramatizing entertainer in a mercantile civilization, we should probably appreciate this historical approach more as her means of living with ballads than as strictly accurate historiography. Despite general disclaimers about dating the ancient myths, legends, and chronicles in orally transmitted poetry, she is continually analyzing various attitudes (e.g. a moral tone, seeing separately versus feeling collectively) and formal devices (first-person expressions, abstractions, precise metaphors, rhyme schemes) as historically significant evidence for early, middle, and late stages in the slow development and decline of folk feeling in ballads. Nevertheless, it seems irrelevant to question the historical status of such apparently traditional and personally felt ideas as, for example, these about Calvinism:
