A new book of poems comes into the world more by stealth than splash. Typically a new book will sell a thousand copies, maybe wo thousand, during its first year. A really successful book may sell three or four thousand, though on rare occasions a book of poems might find twenty or thirty thousand buyers in its early years; this would be a wild blockbuster. Likewise, a book of poems might find itself reviewed in one or two early trade periodicals like Publishers Weekly or Booklist. It might receive three or four notices in literary journals over the next couple of years. It is not unusual for a book of poems—a good book, by an emerging poet, as by an established poet—to pass entirely unmentioned by reviewers and critics.
We are taking the unusual step in The Kenyon Review of presenting two substantial essay—reviews about the same new book of poems. Jorie Graham’s Overlord is a complex work by a major poet. Both of these reviews are generally (certainly not wholly) favorable, though such is not our criterion for a review. Rather, these two reviews came into our office at the same time and convinced us—by the rigor of their critical depth and the difference of their thematic concerns—to run them together. Strong poets need strong critics, Emerson reminds us.
