The Shield Of Achilles by Horace Gregory. Harcourt Brace. $2.50.
Here is a most knowing critic. But let us ask what a critic is; or, first, what happens when a monument of literature—or to be specific when the collected work of a poet—finds its destined or proper reader. Immediately it engages him in a complete psychical response; and that is a considerable activity, though a sympathetic and fairly determinate one. But, beyond that, it may drive him into a counter activity, that is to say, a composition of his own, in which he will register the work objectively, and judge and rationalize it. Though this is a literary activity it is not a primary one, and we had better call it at once a critical activity. The consequence is to augment the public store by a new literary (or critical) essay; it is about the poem or the poet, unless it is about poetry in general or poets. Now within this type of composition there is the greatest variety of performance, including the dull and useless as well as the vital and illuminating. Perhaps nobody will sense the extent of it better than an editor, who has occasion to examine essays not only on the level of publication but on nearly every lower level. Unfortunately, here in America at least, such is the state of “liberal education’’ that he has most frequent experience of a kind of essay which is inferior, and which worldly persons mean to disparage when they refer to it as “academic.” And what is the matter with it?
