A poet’s theories are not always the best guide to his poetry. Wordsworth should not be judged solely from the “Preface” to the Lyrical Ballads, nor Sidney Lanier from his Science of English Verse. Many an admirer of Mr. Eliot, the poet, has been more discouraged than aided by the revelations of Mr. Eliot, the critic. Not so with Gerard Manley Hopkins. His is the almost unique case of a poet who preached what he practised and practised what he preached. As the voluminous comments in his Letters show, his verse conforms to a thesis—a metrical thesis. Understand the thesis, and you grasp his poetic purpose; grasp his purpose, and you have the key to his poems.
This metrical thesis is no simple question of stressed and unstressed syllables. Far more than modern criticism recognizes, it is a cortical strand in the personal tragedy of Hopkins, the man. At the heart of that tragedy, as his letters show, lies artistic loneliness—loneliness no measure of good will could ever dissipate, loneliness made intolerable by the sympathetic but unintuitive good will of Dixon, Bridges, and his other friends. His genius for friendship merely intensified his isolation; he needed not friendship, but a friendly insight capable of penetrating the quickset of obscurities and contradictions which invested his poetic theories. In the beginning, he was sure that the insight was there. Then, completely disillusioned, he pursued a belligerent defensive—immersed himself in prosodic and linguistic studies to justify his metrical innovations to his friends. Towards the end, he was obliged in part to renounce his innovations, his theories, his defense, and even the very practice of poetry itself.
