Matthew Arnold. By Lionel Trilling. W. W. Norton. $3.50
This presentation of Matthew Arnold gives us an admirable book, well written, thoughtful, and dispassionate. It is not, properly, a biography, although it does present such facts of Arnold’s life as seem to be relevant to the main business of the study, the systematic analysis of Arnold’s ideas in their development, and it does undertake to indicate the nature of the relationships existing between his personal history and his ideas. For instance, the youthful Arnold’s Disraelian dandyism, “gay, careless, cocky,” his attitude toward Clough, and his social and aesthetic philosophy are seen by Mr. Trilling as manifestations of the same central impulse, the attempt to define the terms on which a man could be a poet in the England of the mid-Nineteenth Century, a country and a time dedicated to industrial expansion, scientific rationalism, and the political philosophy of Liberalism. The dandyism, the attacks on Clough, represented efforts to flee the “feverish contact,” the strong “infection of our mental strife”; efforts to affirm, in a more personal application, the doctrines of the wholeness of man and the integrity of poetry which became the fundamental concerns of his later criticism. “If we are to understand the relation of Arnold’s poetry to his life,” Mr. Trilling writes, “we must understand the relation of the cockiness to his philosophy; for when the dandyism was at work, Arnold produced poetry, but when the dandyism failed, poetry failed too.” In Hartford, Connecticut, Arnold— not now the Arnold whose unseriousness, years before, had so shocked his friends—met Mark Twain. “But is he never serious?” Arnold demanded. The young Arnold, perhaps, would not have asked precisely that question.
