The most prosperous and barren season in years—this is the current story in a nutshell. For an out-of-town visitor, a select list might read as follows. Othello, because it is Shakespeare and has José Ferrer as lago. The Cherry Orchard, if you have not seen it before. The Two Mrs. Carrolls and last season’s Harriet, if Elizabeth Bergner and Helen Hayes will do. Winged Victory, if you like patriotism liberally sauced with tears. Carmen Jones, because there is some genuine poetry in Oscar Hammerstein II’s trasmogrification of the Carmen libretto into Negro American singing speech. One Touch of Venus, for some original dance-making by Agnes de Mille and for Mary Martin, a young actress of no mean ability. But none of these are theatre evenings without serious blemish. This leaves only The Voice of the Turtle, John van Druten’s artful, three-character comedy, and, of course, Oklahoma! As for the bulk of the thirty-two shows now current on Broadway, the visitor had better spend his time at the Metropolitan Opera House, which such conductors as Beecham, Walter and Pelletier have brought to life, or wait until the spring season of the ballet companies and, it is hoped, a week’s repertory by Martha Graham and her dance company.
Yet harsh judgment may not be the better part of wisdom. It has always been unwise to expect much of theatre, and especially to expect the wrong things. Here, I think, professional aesthetics has been inveterately muddle-headed or just plain ignorant. Has it ever tackled theatre empirically or even known enough about theatre to do so? I find little or nothing in the corpus of traditional theory to help me understand, for example, the perfection of Oklahoma!, the delight I get out of the zany antics of Bobby Clark in Mexican Hayride, or the artful dodges with which the director, George S. Kaufman, has gagged up the impossible script of Ruth Gordon’s. Who would guess from reading the textbooks, even on the theory of drama, that the shadows of script and libretto are cast by reals so concrete and firm as theatre, opera and dance? I raise the point because it would be easy to say right now—it has been said so often before—that the theatre is dying. A way of using the theatre, of giving it extra values, is indeed on its last legs. But this merely means that theatre again is being stripped to the bone, reduced to a craft, shoved back upon the ritual of decorating familiar emotions and myths. We can see it now for what it is: its task show business; its mind essentially (and wisely) illiterate; its instincts that of a jade.
