Going to the theatre this season has been rather like turning unfamiliar corners and coming on familiar scenes. It is not that there has been an absence of surprises, but the unusual, as well as the ordinary, carries its burden of reminiscence. There can be comfort in the familiar, of course, but this year there has more often been dullness.
There has been Eugene O’Neill as usual. His work continues to cause more excitement than that of any living American playwright. His latest success, the twelve-year-old A Touch of the Poet, is not as important or as moving as Long Day’s Journey Into Night. The “new” play, originally conceived as one of a cycle depicting a family history, is another of O’Neill’s studies of the necessity of illusion. His protagonist, Cornelius Melody, has to learn that he is no longer the hero of Talavera, no longer the dashing major who served under Wellington; he is, as his Yankee neighbors assume, simply an Irish tavern-keeper who is too fond of the product he sells. His self-recognition, which is another kind of illusion, one dictated by the society in which he lives, is a kind of spiritual suicide, as painful to his daughter, who has continually cried out against his pretenses, as it is to him. The play comes to life only occasionally—in the angry exchanges between the father and the daughter. The difficulty is that Con Melody is so uninteresting a boor for the first three acts that his tragic fall (O’Neill uses the word tragedy in one of his stage directions) brings neither pain nor purgation. The production did not help much. Since Helen Hayes starred as Con’s Irish peasant wife and since she played too obviously for laughs, she drew attention to herself when it should have been upon the other principals and so wrenched the play out of shape, making even less likely the identification that is necessary in the last act.
