Two Gentle Men: The Lives Of George Herbert And Robert Herrick by Marchette Chute. E. P. Dutton. $5.00.
This is a delightful book for the general reader, especially the general reader interested, as so often happens today, in the relations between poetry and religion. The two writers chosen for recreation in these lively pages afford two admirable illustrations of the possible range of those relations. Both Herbert and Herrick were gentle men in a far from gentle age, and both were poets. Both after very different vicissitudes found shelter under the spacious roof of the Church of England of their day, but their basic relation to the Church was quite different. We can most readily test that relation by asking if they would end up in the Anglican Church if they were living today, and as far as one can ever answer a question involving men of another age, one can be sure that Herbert would have found his way into the Church today as he did then, only he would probably have got there a good deal sooner, for there would be no such tempting short-cuts to religious influence now as was the Court of the Head of the Established Church in the early seventeenth century. And we can be even surer that today Herrick would no more have thought of being a clergyman than he would have thought, as he did for a while, of being a lawyer. He would have ended up much sooner under the great sheltering canvases of the modern university, as so many other poets and artists have done recently.
