The occasion of this brief piece requires a little introduction. A new edition of my book of essays, The World’s Body, will shortly appear from the Louisiana State University Press; the original edition was Scribner’s, in 1938. The editors asked me if I cared to offer any further remarks in my preface; and indeed I cared, and greatly. I had sinned badly as a hostile critic reviewing Mr. Eliot’s drama, Murder in the Cathedral, and that performance required of me an entirely new treatment; but it would be long, longer than the present piece, and must be printed as a postscript at the end of the book. But here I am trying to atone to the reputation of Shakespeare himself, whom in my essay, “Shakespeare at Sonnets,” I had compared unfavorably with Donne in the matter of style. So this is a second postscript. (The Eliot postscript has appeared in The Southern Review.)
And now to my ill report of Shakespeare as compared with Donne. At least I take comfort from seeing that I had not done so badly by Shakespeare as by Eliot. I am pleased to notice that I took many of his sonnets to be metaphysical, like the sonnets of Donne; in respect to their terse and exacting style, their fabulous imagery, and careful arguments. (It is dangerous to deny any kind of merit to Shakespeare.) And I have restudied the sonnets. More of them than I had thought are innocent of my charge of anticlimax in their descending quatrains; and the final couplets are pithier and more adequate to their arguments. Here are two sonnets which turn out better than the opening lines would suggest. Shakespeare has to work for his living, and at the moment is on tour with his fellow actors, a long way from London and the blissful company of his patron, the Earl of Southhampton.
