The Conservative Tradition in America by Allen Guttmann. Oxford University Press, $6.00.
Allen Guttmann’s thesis may be stated briefly, and in his own words. The “Liberal tradition (of which John Locke is fons if not origo) has dominated American political thought and, to a much lesser degree, political behavior.” On the other hand, “While it is true that a political party committed to Burkean Conservatism is almost unthinkable at the present moment, it is nonetheless a fact that Conservatism has persisted in America as an essentially literary phenomenon. Pushed in disarray from the battlefield of political activity, Conservatism has taken refuge in the citadel of ideas. The democratization of American society has made Conservatism increasingly feeble as an institutionalized force, but the Conservative’s dream of a hierarchically structured society of prescribed values and restrained liberty has continued on as an important and usually unrecognized aspect of American literature.” Thus Guttmann: the political tradition is liberal, while the literary tradition has important conservative aspects.
