New Directions 1940 edited by James Laughlin. New Directions. $3.50.
Mr. Laughlin’s new collection is larger and handsomer than its predecessors, and he says in the preface that he has paid special attention this time to “instinctive” form and discipline, but the general character of New Directions has not changed: a few solid excellent pieces, many lame ducks, some aimless experiment, a few freaks. New features are a long section on Surrealism and the absence of any really good verse. I propose to begin with the lame ducks, since reviewers commonly ignore them and Mr. Laughlin with a touching but reprehensible loyalty has been printing them or their stand-ins for years. The worst poetry, then, and it is excruciating, is by Charles Henri Ford, Paul Goodman, Eugene Jolas, Hubert Creekmore and George Kauffman. Terrible also are the “chain-poems” written by the Vou Club, the New Apocalypse Group, and other misguided persons. The prose is better than the poetry. Only Parker Tyler’s article is thoroughly bad, and there are distinguished contributions by George Orwell, Katherine Anne Porter, Alfred Young Fisher and James Agee. Orwell’s is an impressive essay called “Inside the Whale,” the first good study of Henry Miller and a penetrating account of literary movements since the first World War. Critical also, and very interesting, are the ten pages of excerpts from Miss Porter’s Journal. Of the stories, Fisher’s “Death and Burial” is much the best, imperfect but ambitious and moving; Eudora Welty’s story, although good, is slighter, and Weldon Kees’s is clumsy in its detail. Perhaps finest of all is the “Colon” from Agee’s and Walker Evans’s forthcoming book on the sharecroppers, Let Us Now Praise Famous Men; Agee’s prose is sensitive, strenuous, exact. These four pieces show in their diversity and excellence what Mr. Laughlin can accomplish with New Directions when his judgment is not betrayed by his desire to represent, to be experimental, to be kind, to be catholic.
