I find it hard, and I think it would be false, to write of Sherwood Anderson without speaking of him personally and even emotionally. I did not know him; I was in his company only twice and neither time did I speak with him. The first time I saw him was when he was at the height of his fame; I had, I recall, just been reading A Story Teller’s Story and Tar and they had confirmed the feeling which had already been strong for a few years that what Anderson had to offer was insufficient. The second occasion was about two years ago; he had not for a long time figured in my own thinking about literature and I believe that most people were no longer aware of him as an immediate literary force in their lives: his last two novels (Beyond Desire, 1932, and Kit Brandon, 1936) had not been good, they were all too clearly an attempt to catch up with the world, but the world had moved too fast; it was not that Anderson was not aware of the state of things but rather that he had suffered the fate of the writer who, at one brief past moment, has had a success with a simple idea which he allowed to remain simple and to become fixed. On both occasions—the first among a group of eager Wisconsin students and of young instructors who were a little worried that this Odysseus, the first famous man of letters most of us had ever seen, would think us stuffy and academic, the second at a crowded New York party—I was much taken by Anderson’s human quality, by a certain serious interest he could have in the person he was shaking hands with or talking to for a formal moment, by a certain graciousness or gracefulness which seemed to arise from an innocence of heart.
I mention this very tenuous personal impression not because it has any interest in itself—it so obviously has none—but because it must really have arisen not at all from my observation of the moment but rather to have been projected from some unconscious residue of admiration I had for Anderson’s books even after I had made all my adverse judgments upon them. It existed when I undertook to write this notice of him or else I should not have undertaken it. And now that I have gone back to his books again and have found that I like them even less than I remembered, I find that the residue of admiration still remains; it is quite vague yet it requires to be articulated with the clearer feelings of dissatisfaction; it requires too, I think, that it be spoken of, as it has been, first.
