Read the winning piece of our 2025 Nonfiction Contest “Through the Mirror” by Jessie Cato selected by Lucy Ives.

Read

Autumn 1945 • Vol. VII No. 4 • Nonfiction |

A Music Letter from England

It is almost certainly true that not in living memory has there been so much musical activity as there is in London at the present. The London Philharmonic Arts Club, the concerts promoted by the French government, the International Arts Guild, the Committee for the Promotion of New Music, the Boosey and Hawkes concerts and the Gerald Cooper chamber concerts are regularly presenting as much contemporary and “unusual” music in a month as before the war one was likely to hear in a year; indeed there is so much on that one is forced to make a selection from the things one would like, or ought, to hear. It is true that the audience at all these ventures does not appreciably expand; the old familiar faces crop up whatever the aegis under which the performance is given: and it is true that big orchestral concerts, preferably of music of the 19th Century, including one of “the” piano concertos, are the only manifestations at all likely to tickle the ear of the great British public. London’s “progressive” public has woken up but compared with the total population it is extremely small. It is difficult to gauge the cultural temper of the country until one has more evidence as to the kind of response similar work would meet with in the provinces. In any case what is in question is the kind of relation there is between the music and these small progressive audiences. If it is a genuinely vital relation the size need not trouble us; an educated minority will then gradually disseminate its enlightenment, without of course any conscious effort on its part, and will thus give direction to the emotionally inchoate hordes to whom C.E.M.A. and the like admirable democratic institutions are giving their first musical experience. The two activities are, or should be, complementary; democracy gives the opportunity, but it is still up to the educated minority to offer the appropriate values and standards. Without them, musical uplift is as dangerous as any other kind, perhaps more so because it is less susceptible to irony.

The nature and quality of the “progressive” audience is therefore of supreme importance. A friend actively engaged in one of the ventures referred to at the beginning of this note adopted in conversation with me on the subject an extremely gloomy tone. According to him there was a good deal of intellectual snobism involved (there’d always be a measure of that, of course) and the tremendous success of Britten’s Peter Grimes was more due to the publicity barrage than to an appreciation of the merits of the music. He has more direct experience of the London public than I have, and he may be right. I am inclined to think however that he may be prejudiced through working in conjunction with the French government, which manifests a generosity and intelligence in its cultural propaganda (if we may use so discredited a word without pejorative implication) that both the British and the United States governments would do well to emulate. (The French Government sent the conductor Roger Desormieres to London especially to see if Peter Grimes was worth presenting in Paris; can we imagine the British Government sending Adrian Boult on a comparable mission to France!) There can be no doubt that this “official” generosity and intelligence is a reflection of the extraordinarily high vitality of French musical culture as a whole, and this of course is attributable partly to a long established tradition, and partly to the ardent need for aesthetic satisfaction which the privations of war have encouraged. While a certain percentage of the British progressive boom must be discounted, however, I believe there is a bigger core to it than my friend imagines, and (as he willingly admits) certain evidence in support of this optimism was provided by the very remarkable concert given early in July, by members of the Dartington Hall Music Group, of music by Monteverdi.

Already have an account? Log in

Join KR for even more to read.

Sign up for a free account and read any five pieces a month.
Sign Up and Read for Free



Or become a subscriber today and get complete, immediate access to our digital archives at every subscription level.

Read More

Subscribe

Your free registration with The Kenyon Review includes access to exclusive content, early access to program registration, and more.

Donate

With your support, we’ll continue 
to cultivate talent and publish extraordinary literature from diverse voices around the world.