“Music is of all arts the nearest to the abstract sense … the most nearly related to Nature: not to its forms but to its being.”
— Ferrucio Busoni.
There never was a more imbecile notion than the 20th Century cult of Pure Music for the simple reason that although in one sense all music must be programme music since it is concerned with human emotions, in another sense music, in so far as it is music, can never be anything but pure. No one could ever prove, though it is always being said, that Beethoven is a “more philosophical” composer than Mozart; there is a very real distinction implied but it is one that can be made only in terms of quality and kind of emotional response. One has just got to admit that as soon as one starts to use words to describe the effect of music one is to some extent interpreting in non-musical terms something which is not the music but which is more or less closely related to it. It remains for the critic to seek verbal correlations for, or references to, certain psychological attitudes which are implicit in the created experience which the music is, to train the mind of the listener to seize on only those particulars which are, or seem to the best of his comprehension to be, relevant to the sincere response to the musical experience involved. Obviously the distinction as to where exactly the borderline is to be drawn between what is relevant to the musical experience and what isn’t, rests ultimately on personal judgment; but something parallel to this seems to me to be true of any sort of criticism whatever.
