Surely D. H. Lawrence’s fictions have their affirmation of love, of immediate, passionate and physical eros. But it is also true that much of Lawrence’s fiction is peculiarly unloving, unaffirmative, and even violently negative. It seems likely that an extended analysis of Lawrence’s work might demonstrate that the very insistence on the irrational and amoral erotic is a desperate effort to match his equally insistent perceptions of the perverse and destructive center of both ordinary and idealistic behavior. In briefer compass we might at least delineate some of the nihilism which is as characteristic of the Laurentian literature as is erotic love. A close reading of two of his better short fictions, one early and one late, may also help in pointing a corrective finger at much of the recent sentimental and moralistic criticism of Lawrence. A counter-emphasis from the fashionable desire to make literature into pietistic affirmations of “creativity” is due. Lawrence, with one of his peculiar insights, as a literary critic, sanctions such a point: “You have to have something vicious in you to be a creative writer. It is the something vicious, old- Adamislh, incompatible to the ‘ordinary’ world, inside a man, which gives an edge to his awareness.”
The story “The Prussian Officer” is a pre-World War I tale written in Lawrence’s early manner of sensuous elaboration of a melodramatic episode. The line of the story is quite simple. A young peasant orderly hates his harsh superior officer, is mistreated, rebels, kills the officer in a moment of rage, and dies in his flight. The concluding scene of the officer and the orderly “together, side by side, in the mortuary” emphasizes the obvious irony of the equal end for the warped authority and the desperate rebel.
