Promises By Robert Penn Warren. Random House. $3.00.
Although it is possible, generally speaking, to discover certain con- sistently developing themes in Mr. Warren’s work—prose and verse alike—it is nevertheless impossible to know just what he will do next. In our own century he is perhaps the only American writer who, having already established his major importance, remains unpredictable. If anyone has noted any similarity between Mr. Warren and, say, Dickens, I should be surprised and delighted. But the two authors share the power—it is a very great power, and perhaps it is the heart of the poetic imagination—of unpredictability. A critic is right in being a little hesitant about such a writer. But how explain the neglect of Mr. Warren’s poems when we compare it with the critical concern with his novels? I use the word “neglect” when I speak of the poems, simply because I have a hunch that they contain the best seedings and harvests of his imagination.
