A. E. Housman: Scholar and Poet by Norman Marlow. University of Minnesota. $3.50.
Mr. Marlow contends that his poet, for whom he feels “admiration and even veneration,” has been ill-treated, or not treated at all: “Twenty years after Housman’s death there is still no comprehensive study of his poetry in English and very little balanced criticism of it.” To set this matter straight is a praiseworthy ambition, but Mr. Miarlow’s performance is unconvincing, though I suppose competent at the routine scholarly duties which occupy two-thirds of the book, and I finished his course more doubtful of Housman’s quality than before. Rereading the poems decided me that Mr. Marlow, rather than the poet, was responsible for this sorry result.
